orange felt (cut into pumpkin shape)
black felt (cut into various shapes for face)
pumpkin faces (These are optional. I saw them in the Target Dollar spot and knew they would be perfect for this project.)
I did something similar to this last year but Emerson was just too little to really get it. She played with the pieces a little bit, but she wasn't really all that interested. She seemed to enjoy it a lot more this year. It's also nice that it's another activity that can be pulled out and utilized throughout the month. It's easy to prepare and easy to clean up, so it's a definite win in my book!